Skip to main content

Chelsea · Est. in the heart of Manhattan

Good morning, neighbors — come on in.

Your corner bakery and grocer on West 23rd Street, where the bread is still warm, the shelves are always stocked, and everyone who walks through our door is treated like family.

Freshly baked bread and pastries displayed on a rustic bakery counter

About Us

A neighborhood staple since day one

Romeo and Juliet 23rd Street has been a quiet fixture on one of Chelsea's most walkable blocks — a place where the morning rush smells like butter and brown sugar, and where regulars know the baker by name.

What started as a small dream to bring something honest and homemade to the block has grown into a neighborhood institution. We bake in small batches, order our produce with the same care you would, and keep our doors open because we genuinely love being part of this community.

Whether you're grabbing a quick coffee and a croissant before work, picking up ingredients for Sunday dinner, or treating yourself to a slice of something special — there's always a seat for you here.

— With love and flour on our aprons

What We Offer

From the oven and the shelf

Everything we serve or sell is chosen with the same standard: would we want it on our own table?

Fresh Baked Goods

Artisan breads, flaky croissants, danishes, and seasonal pastries — all baked on-site each morning from scratch.

Grocery Essentials

A curated selection of pantry staples, fresh produce, dairy, and everyday items — the kind of neighborhood grocer that's harder to find than you'd think.

Special Orders

Celebrating something? We take custom cake and pastry orders for birthdays, anniversaries, and quiet Sundays that feel like celebrations.

Open Early, Closed Late

Convenience matters. We open early for the morning crowd and stay open late so your evening plans are never ruined by forgetting one thing at the store.

Interior of a warm, inviting bakery with wooden shelves and fresh bread
A close-up of a golden pastry dusted with powdered sugar on a marble surface

Our Story

Built on the belief that a good neighborhood deserves a good bakery

Chelsea has always been a neighborhood that moves fast — commuters rushing to the subway, families walking dogs past brownstones, artists finding their studios. But somewhere between the rush, there are people who stop. Who notice the smell of something baking. Who decide this is the place.

Romeo and Juliet 23rd Street was born from that kind of moment. We didn't set out to be the best bakery in New York. We wanted to be the best bakery for the people who live, work, and walk past our door every day. That distinction matters to us — it's the difference between a business and a home.

Every loaf we pull from the oven, every shelf we stock, every smile we offer at the counter — it's all part of the same promise. You come in as a customer. You leave as a neighbor.

Visit Us

We'd love to see you

537 W 23rd St
New York, NY 10011-1102

(718) 674-5460

info@cafebythegirls.com

Hours

  • Monday7:00 AM – 8:00 PM
  • Tuesday7:00 AM – 8:00 PM
  • Wednesday7:00 AM – 8:00 PM
  • Thursday7:00 AM – 8:00 PM
  • Friday7:00 AM – 9:00 PM
  • Saturday8:00 AM – 9:00 PM
  • Sunday8:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Holiday hours may vary — give us a call to confirm.
Is this your business?This is my business